

At my local shop the other day:
The Games Vault there was a Roman Day which featured a superb demonstration of a tabletop battle between two Roman armies.
There was a lot of civil unrest in those days but this was not just a clash between two Roman generals. This was a clash of metal versus plastic!
One army was all metal, (looked great but cost a fortune), the other was all plastic, (looked superb but was a fraction of the price).
The plastics came from Warlord and can be bought through
The Games Vault and are brilliant value for money.
Both armies were painted to a good "tabletop" standard. The plastics were painted using Army Painter products - which is where my ears pricked up!
To me, this way of painting is like "The Dark Side" but you've got to try and have an open mind about these things, (I suppose). The idea is that very quickly you can have a playable army without the months of painstaking painting. Or having all grey plastic/all black primed ranks, (boring).
After a brief outline of how it all works from Paul of
Warwickshire Gamers I rushed downstairs and bought some pink spray; some silver spray; a tin of "dark tone" and very importantly: a tin of matt varnish spray.
Then, just as I'd pulled my card out to pay I spotted a bottle of Vallejo Sepia Wash. Vallejo make my favourite paints so felt I had to buy this as well.
The Army Painter tin cost £18.50 and the Vallejo wash cost £6.00
I also bought a box of Romans and a box of Ancient British. Now was the real clash of the day!
The gonks were both excellent value and easy to make.
The next stage was to spray them in the colour that covers most of the figure, (flesh for the Brits and silver for the Romans).
Once this was dry - about an hour - I painted straight onto this base with a few flat colours leaving the majority of the figure silver, (or flesh).
I then split the forces. Half for the Army Painter Team and half for the Vallejo Team.
Then comes the messy part. Both the Army Painter and the Vallejo products indicate that the gonk should be dipped into the tin/bottle. (The idea being you shake off any excess leaving enough for the recessed parts). This is way too messy and in my opinion a waste of time.
I got two large brushes and painted liberally all over each team. (NOTE: Army Painter is spirit based and needs turps to clean you and the brushes).
Then the long wait. (Well long for the Army Painter - I actually suggest overnight...)
The next day I was left with two halves of the gonks I had made up. One was very, very shiny.
I sprayed both with the Matt Varnish and again waited for drying. (Not long as it happens).
OK.
The Gonk Machine Verdict.
If I was to be painting either a massed barbarian horde or legions of Romans then both the coloured sprays worked well. There was no need to have another primer like Citadel Chaos Black which I use all the time.
Using these sprays would really save a lot of time as long as there was total coverage without any plastic showing.
Painting red or flesh over the silver spray was a bit of a pain but with big armies you're not looking for complete perfection , (spend more tome on your characters!).
The Army Painter tin was horrible to use. It was sticky and seemed to get everywhere. I also had to use white spirit to wash the brush out with. This means that I can only use this brush for spirit based paints and will shorten the brushes lifespan considerable.
When the figures were dry, the shine from the army painter was so reflective that it hurt my eyes!
Vallejo dried very quickly and matt.
The matt spray was good and as I will always matt varnish a gonk it saved some time.
In short: Vallejo wins the day, with a bit of help from The coloured Army Painter spray. (Also it was a third of the price!).
There were two Brits and one Roman for each team. (Left or right in the photos).
You decide which worked better.